I am 90% percent sure he'd be even more terrifying than Croatverse Dean. Everything we've seen of him when he's lost Dean - in tricksterverse or to hell - is crazy scary. Dude. Shit. I wonder if he'd even make it, you know? Like, not really go darkside but if he could hold those people together and keep them hoping for any kind of victory.
man, now I really really want to read what other people think of Croatverse Sam. which I'm assuming they have? right?